Donut SMP Obsidian Farming: Wither Setup, Earnings and Risks
Understand the portal-based farming loop, essential setup checks, storage requirements and the difference between gross sales and actual profit.
Overview
Learn how a portal-based obsidian farm works, which components keep it running, and how to judge its earnings without overlooking startup costs or raid exposure. This Donut SMP setup combines four Withers, linked portal machinery and bulk storage to turn regenerated portal frames into saleable blocks.
The attraction is high-volume production, but the machinery requires more preparation than a simple collection farm. A successful build depends on reliable portal placement, controlled Wither targeting and collection that can keep pace with output.
How the Obsidian Farming Loop Works
The farm repeatedly generates portal frames, then uses Withers to break the obsidian for collection. Hoppers gather the drops, while storage holds the output until it can be sold or packed into shulker boxes.
This is a two-sided installation: the harvesting setup works alongside machinery on the Nether side. A chest feeds items into a dropper or dispenser arrangement that sends them through a portal as part of the regeneration cycle. The described setup uses obsidian in that supply chest and starts its Nether machinery through a note block.
The important distinction is that the farm harvests newly generated portal frames. Simply placing Withers beside an ordinary portal does not reproduce the full system. Portal positioning, regeneration machinery and mob placement must all follow a compatible design.
Demand determines how useful that output becomes. Expensive obsidian can make the method attractive for earning Donut SMP money, but a productive machine does not guarantee a particular selling price.
Requirements Before You Build
Treat this as an advanced farm rather than a low-budget starting project. Beyond construction materials, it needs dangerous mobs, supporting accounts and enough storage to prevent a collection backlog.
- Four Withers: the harvesting design relies on this number, so do not assume fewer will perform identically.
- Linked portal infrastructure: both sides need the correct arrangement for the regeneration cycle.
- Iron golems: these provide the intended targets for the Withers.
- Hoppers and chests: collection must move harvested blocks away from the breaking area.
- A supply chest and item-delivery mechanism: these support the portal machinery.
- Buttons: placement around the machinery helps prevent unwanted portal generation locations.
- Two alternate accounts: the described arrangement uses these to keep the setup operating.
- Shulker storage: an automatic loader is useful when ordinary chests fill quickly.
The arrangement also includes water above the Withers, boats and a TNT mechanism. Their placement is design-specific; they should not be treated as optional decorations or moved casually. Use a complete, compatible build layout rather than improvising the dangerous sections.
Budget for More Than Construction Blocks
Include mob-summoning materials, collection components, shulker boxes and replacement supplies in your initial budget. Money tied up in these components is not recovered until sales cover that investment.
Keep a reserve outside the project. Spending an entire balance on construction leaves little room to repair a fault or replace lost equipment. For players comparing Donut SMP items, functional collection and safe operation matter more here than expensive personal gear.
Setup Checks That Prevent Common Failures
Control Where Portals Generate
Unwanted portal placement can disrupt the machinery. Buttons are used to restrict potential generation positions around the build, helping keep new frames where the harvesting system expects them.
Check this protection before starting a long session. A machine that generates a portal in the wrong place may stop producing properly or interfere with nearby components. Adding storage will not solve a portal-placement problem.
Keep Withers Focused on Iron Golems
The intended behavior is for the Withers to target iron golems rather than players. Summoning them is therefore only one part of commissioning the farm: their targeting must also settle correctly.
A brief disconnect and reconnect is used in the described startup procedure before checking their targets. Treat that as a setup step, not proof that targeting will remain correct indefinitely. Observe the mobs after returning and verify that the golems have their attention.
Do not leave the farm unattended while a Wither is targeting a player. Avoid unnecessary movement near the harvesting section once the system is active, and stop testing if the mob behavior is wrong.
Take a look at: compare money farms and their practical trade-offs
Test Collection Before Extended Operation
Run a short test after lighting the portal and activating the machinery. Watch whether portal frames regenerate, harvested blocks reach the hoppers, and storage accepts the incoming items.
Inspect the shulker loader separately. A working harvesting loop can still lose practical value if its loader jams, sends boxes incorrectly or leaves output uncollected. Confirm that filled boxes are stored as intended before committing to an hour-long run.
Storage Capacity and Bulk Handling
Obsidian stacks to 64, and a full shulker box holds 27 stacks, or 1,728 blocks. A double chest containing 54 completely filled shulker boxes therefore represents 93,312 blocks. That is very different from a double chest filled directly with loose obsidian.
This distinction matters when estimating inventory value. Saying that a double chest is worth a certain amount is meaningless unless its contents are clear.
- Count full shulker boxes separately from partially filled boxes.
- Include loose stacks when measuring total production.
- Keep empty boxes available for the loader.
- Check that the final storage has space before a long run.
A loader reduces manual handling, but it does not remove the need for inspections. Storage capacity should match the length of the planned farming session, not merely the first few minutes of output.
How Much Can the Farm Earn?
A demonstrated one-hour run produced approximately 8 million in gross sales. That is a useful benchmark for this setup, not a guaranteed hourly return. Production stability, downtime, storage performance and available sale prices all affect the result.
Illustrative full-shulker valuations ranged around 1.6–1.7 million. At those valuations, a double chest containing 54 full boxes would represent approximately 86.4–91.8 million. Those figures describe inventory value under particular prices, not the time needed to produce or sell it.
A straight multiplication of the hourly benchmark gives 192 million over 24 hours. That calculation assumes uninterrupted operation and unchanged selling conditions. It should not be treated as a reliable daily forecast, especially for a farm vulnerable to discovery.
Measure Net Profit, Not Just Sales
To estimate actual profit, subtract operating expenses from completed sales. To calculate payback time, also account for the initial construction investment. Items sitting in storage are potential revenue rather than a finished sale.
For a useful test, record:
- The amount of obsidian already present before starting.
- The exact duration of the run.
- Full boxes, partial boxes and loose stacks produced.
- Actual proceeds from selling that output.
- Supplies consumed, repairs and any downtime.
Keeping these measurements separate prevents old stock or unrelated income from inflating the farm's apparent performance.
Choosing Where to Sell Obsidian
The available selling routes described for this method include the auction house, player orders and /sell. Compare the amount offered for the same quantity before choosing a route.
A higher advertised listing price is not automatically better than a lower immediate sale. Check whether there is enough demand to move your output, particularly when selling multiple shulker boxes.
Use a small batch to test the return before committing a large stockpile. Calculate the value per stack or per block consistently so that differently sized offers remain comparable. This is especially important when an order accepts only part of your inventory.
Take a look at: bone meal farming profits and raid risk
Discovery Risk and Long-Term Reliability
The major drawback is exposure: this style of farm can be found, and losing the installation can erase much of its financial advantage. Its value depends on how much usable output it produces before a failure, interruption or raid.
Avoid leaving all accumulated output at the production site. Moving completed stock reduces the amount tied to one vulnerable installation, although it does not protect the machinery itself.
Evaluate the setup through three separate questions:
- Does it regenerate and harvest portals consistently?
- Can storage and sales handle the volume?
- Can the project recover its construction cost before a major loss?
A strong hourly result answers only part of that assessment. Reliable operation and controlled exposure are what turn a promising farm into a sustainable income method.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many Withers does this farm need?
The described design uses four. Its portal harvesting and mob arrangement should not be assumed to work unchanged with fewer.
Do you need alternate accounts?
This arrangement calls for two alternate accounts. Account positioning and operation must match the complete design for the farm to function as intended.
Is 8 million per hour guaranteed?
No. It is a demonstrated gross-sales benchmark. Your return depends on reliable production, collection, selling prices and operating costs.
Why are buttons placed around the machinery?
They help restrict unwanted portal generation positions. Incorrect portal placement can interfere with the farm and stop the intended harvesting loop.
Should you add a shulker loader?
It is useful for sustained production because it packs output into manageable containers. Test it carefully and provide enough empty boxes and final storage space.