OSRS Mining and Smithing Rework: Goals, Progression and Player Feedback
Skilling Mining Smithing

OSRS Mining and Smithing Rework: Goals, Progression and Player Feedback

Looking to progress faster? Grab Old School RuneScape Gold from Elyxir.

Buy OSRS Gold
Looking to progress faster? Grab Old School RuneScape Gold from Elyxir. Buy OSRS Gold

OSRS Mining and Smithing Rework: Goals, Progression and Player Feedback

Understand why these skills are being reconsidered and which design questions matter most.

MiningSmithingSkilling
OSRS Mining and Smithing Rework: Goals, Progression and Player Feedback - A smith hammers a rune platebody into shape with precision.
A smith hammers a rune platebody into shape with precision.

Overview

Learn why Mining and Smithing are being reconsidered in Old School RuneScape, why Smithing attracts stronger calls for a rework, and what meaningful improvements would need to achieve. The central issue is not simply making experience faster: it is giving progression a purpose while preserving what players already enjoy.

Why Mining and Smithing Are Under Discussion

Mining and Smithing form one of the game's most recognisable production chains: gather ore, smelt bars, then turn those bars into equipment. That connection gives both skills a clear identity, but it does not automatically make every stage of training feel rewarding.

Mod Rice has described player survey results in which both skills received substantial dissatisfaction. Importantly, the demand for a full rework leaned more heavily toward Smithing. That distinction matters because improving two connected skills does not necessarily mean changing them in the same way.

Mining has questions around its activities, pacing and rewards. Smithing also faces a particularly visible question about the relationship between the level required to make equipment and the stage at which that equipment is useful.

The discussion establishes a direction, not a finished design. Ideas shared by an individual developer should not be treated as confirmed mechanics, reward lists or release commitments.

Why Smithing Progression Draws So Much Criticism

Making Equipment and Using It Are Different Milestones

A familiar example is the rune platebody. Smithing one requires level 99 Smithing, while wearing one requires 40 Defence and completion of Dragon Slayer I. Those requirements belong to different progression systems, but their distance helps explain why players question the production ladder.

Reaching a major manufacturing milestone does not necessarily unlock equipment that improves the account's combat setup. Tradeable equipment is also available through the Grand Exchange, so a main account rarely needs to produce every upgrade personally.

This does not mean that every item should be equally difficult to make and equip. Production skills can support trade, supply other players and provide useful services. The challenge is ensuring that the journey still feels worthwhile to the person training it.

A Skill Can Have Uses Without Feeling Meaningful

Smithing already has established purposes. It supports quests and diaries, produces equipment and ammunition components, and offers distinct training options through activities such as Giants' Foundry and the Blast Furnace.

Nevertheless, a list of uses does not fully answer why a player might find progression unsatisfying. An unlock can be technically useful yet feel disconnected from the player's goals. Equally, an efficient training method can solve an experience problem without solving a reward problem.

That is why feedback such as “the skill has no meaning” requires interpretation. It could describe weak milestones, limited personal utility, an unappealing training loop or an expectation that gathering and production should connect more naturally.

Mining Needs Its Own Diagnosis

The survey distinction argues against treating Mining as simply the first half of a Smithing problem. Mining already includes different styles of play, from concentrated iron mining and granite training to more relaxed activities such as Motherlode Mine and Shooting Stars.

Those options appeal to different players. Some value frequent interaction and optimisation; others want steady progress with fewer inputs. Improving satisfaction therefore requires more precision than deciding that all training should become faster or more active.

  • Activity: Does the method offer an appropriate level of interaction?
  • Progression: Do new levels unlock something players anticipate?
  • Rewards: Is the output useful enough to justify gathering it?
  • Identity: Does the activity still feel like Mining?

A change can improve one of these areas while weakening another. Making a relaxed method more demanding, for example, could disappoint the players who chose it specifically for its lower intensity.

Meaningful Rewards Without Unnecessary Bloat

One of the clearest design tensions is between players who want new rewards and players who do not want unnecessary additions. These positions are not inherently incompatible.

A meaningful reward does not have to be another equipment tier or a large collection of narrowly useful items. In principle, improving an existing unlock or making an established production step more relevant could provide value without expanding the item catalogue substantially. These are ways to assess a proposal, not announced features.

The important test is whether an addition solves an identifiable problem. A new item that exists only to justify another unlock may add complexity without making either skill more satisfying.

Conversely, avoiding all new rewards could leave progression feeling unchanged. The goal is not simply fewer items or more items, but rewards that earn their place.

Room for Optional Skill Expression

Mod Rice has also expressed an interest in small mechanical interactions that allow players to discover unexpected optimisations. The broader design idea is that a straightforward activity can contain extra depth without requiring everyone to engage with it.

For skilling, that raises a useful question: can attentive play offer interesting decisions while leaving a comfortable baseline intact? Optional optimisation can give dedicated players something to master, but it becomes less optional if ordinary training feels unreasonably poor without it.

No specific tick-saving Mining or Smithing mechanic should be assumed from that design preference. It is better understood as an interest in emergent gameplay rather than a promised feature.

OSRS Mining and Smithing Rework: Goals, Progression and Player Feedback - Miners swing pickaxes and carry ore for further processing.
Miners swing pickaxes and carry ore for further processing.

What Economic Changes Would Need to Consider

Mining and Smithing connect directly to tradeable resources, so changes to their outputs or resource consumption could affect prices. However, without final mechanics, there is no reliable basis for predicting which ores, bars or finished items would rise or fall.

For players budgeting their OSRS gold, the practical distinction is between buying supplies for actual training and buying them as a speculative investment. The former serves a known account goal; the latter depends on unconfirmed assumptions.

Any assessment of skilling profitability also needs to distinguish revenue from profit. Purchased materials, processing costs and the time required all matter. A more valuable finished item does not automatically make its production method better.

Ironman players face a different calculation because they cannot trade with other players. Resource availability and the usefulness of self-produced supplies matter more directly than GE margins. A successful design needs to consider both experiences without assuming that one reward structure serves every account equally.

Why Player Feedback Is Central

Survey results can identify dissatisfaction, but they cannot always explain its cause. Two players can both dislike Smithing while wanting very different solutions: one may want more useful equipment, while another wants a better training experience.

Useful evaluation separates the problem from a preferred fix. Instead of judging a proposal only by whether it increases experience rates, consider whether it addresses the original frustration.

  • Does the change create a milestone worth pursuing?
  • Does it preserve training styles that already have an audience?
  • Does it improve the connection between resources and useful outputs?
  • Does it offer value beyond completing a quest or diary requirement?
  • Does it introduce complexity proportionate to its benefits?

The strongest outcome would make progression more satisfying without erasing the skills' identities. That requires balancing utility, training variety, economic effects and the different reasons players log in to skill.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are the Mining and Smithing rework mechanics confirmed?

The ideas discussed here are design goals and considerations, not a final specification. Specific mechanics, rewards and requirements should not be assumed.

Why does Smithing attract stronger calls for a rework?

A major concern is the disconnect between manufacturing milestones and equipment usefulness. Survey feedback described by Mod Rice also showed stronger demand for reworking Smithing than Mining.

Should players stop training these skills?

Existing quest, diary and account goals remain practical reasons to train. Speculative changes alone are not a strong basis for abandoning useful progression.

Will ores and bars become more expensive?

There is no dependable prediction without concrete changes to supply and demand. Treat claims about guaranteed price movements cautiously.

Would improvements only matter to Ironman accounts?

No. Main accounts also benefit from satisfying unlocks and worthwhile training. Ironman accounts simply experience resource gathering and production more directly because they cannot obtain supplies through player trading.

Matt Parker

About Matt Parker

A lifelong MMORPG enthusiast, Matt has spent countless hours exploring worlds like the EverQuest series and RuneScape. With a deep love for old-school progression, player-driven economies, and virtual adventure, they write to share insights, nostalgia, and hard-earned knowledge from years inside these iconic games.

View all posts by Matt Parker